top of page

Painting vs. Siding: Pros and Cons for Your Home's Exterior


Repainting your Home's exterior vs getting new siding.  In this article we will go through the differences in cost, aesthetics, maintenance, and overall value.

Is your home beginning to show signs of wear, making you feel as if it's losing its former charm? The exterior of a home serves as the first impression for guests, neighbors, and potential buyers. It plays a pivotal role in determining both curb appeal and overall property value. As time wears on and styles evolve, homeowners often find themselves at a crossroads, contemplating how best to rejuvenate their home's façade. Two of the most sought-after solutions are repainting and installing new siding. In this post, we'll delve into the pros and cons of both, helping you make an informed decision for your home.


What is Repainting?

Repainting is the process of applying a new coat of paint over an existing one or directly onto a surface to refresh its appearance. This practice has been used for centuries, serving both aesthetic and protective purposes.


Types of Exterior Paints and Their Uses:

Latex (Water-Based) Paint

This is one of the most common types of exterior paint. It dries quickly, is durable, and resists yellowing with age. Latex paint cleans up easily with soap and water, making it user-friendly. It's especially suitable for wood, stucco, and masonry.


Oil-Based Paint

This type offers a smooth, high-quality finish that resists chipping. It's especially useful for metals and woods that bleed, like redwood and cedar, as it blocks stains. However, cleanup requires solvents, and the paint may take longer to dry.


Acrylic Paint

A subset of latex paint, acrylic is known for its superior durability and longevity. It's resistant to fading and UV rays, making it perfect for exteriors exposed to harsh sunlight.


Choosing the right paint for your home goes beyond just selecting a captivating color. The market is flooded with numerous brands and qualities of paint, each promising durability and a flawless finish. However, not all paints are created equal. Some cheaper options might be tempting for the wallet, but they often lack coverage, longevity, and resistance to environmental factors. Opting for a well-regarded and reputable brand, even if it comes at a premium, can mean the difference between a paint job that fades, chips, or peels within a year and one that retains its vibrancy and protection for many years to come. Think of it as an investment; paying a bit more now for a top-tier paint can save significant amounts in touch-ups and repaints down the road. At Zajac painting, we understand the longevity and beauty of your home's exterior are at stake, that’s why we proudly use Sherwin Williams products on all of our projects.


Advantages of Repainting

Cost

For homeowners operating on a tight budget, a new coat of paint can yield a transformative effect without a hefty price tag. If you're willing to roll up your sleeves and take the DIY route, the costs can be even more palatable. By eliminating labor fees, which often comprise a significant portion of professional services, and only investing in paint and a few essential tools, homeowners can give their residence a revamped look at a fraction of the price. However, even if you decide to entrust the task to a professional painter, the expenses associated with repainting typically remain considerably lower than those of siding installation. The reason is that while both tasks require labor, siding materials often come at a higher cost than paint, and the installation process can be more intricate and time-consuming. Interested in knowing how much of an investment having your home repainted would be? Contact Us to schedule a free estimate today


Flexibility

One of the standout advantages of paint is its innate flexibility in offering homeowners a broad spectrum of color choices. Unlike siding, which typically comes in a set range of colors unless custom-ordered, paint offers virtually limitless options. If you're someone who values the freedom to change aesthetics on a whim or follow evolving design trends, paint provides that adaptability. Siding, on the other hand, while durable and long-lasting, doesn't grant the same ease of color transformation. If homeowners opt for a specific color outside of the standard range, it generally involves a custom order, which invariably comes at a premium. Thus, repainting not only allows you to frequently refresh your home's exterior palette but also gives you a cost-efficient method to do so, as opposed to the pricier and less diverse color options available with siding.


Protection

While the aesthetic transformation a fresh coat of paint brings is undeniably alluring, its protective properties often go underappreciated. A high-quality paint acts as a robust barrier, safeguarding the home against various environmental aggressors. From the relentless assault of UV rays, which can fade and degrade surfaces over time, to the persistent threat of moisture that might lead to mold or structural damage, a well-applied coat offers formidable defense. Additionally, certain paints come with properties that deter insects, an invaluable feature, especially for homes with wooden exteriors prone to termite infestations.


Disadvantages of Repainting

Maintenance

Regardless of the type of siding, consistent maintenance becomes a focal point when relying on paint to protect and beautify a home's exterior. Every material, be it wood, vinyl, aluminum, or stucco, interacts with paint in distinct ways and presents unique challenges. Fluctuating temperatures can cause most materials to expand and contract, potentially leading to paint chipping or peeling. Moisture is a universal adversary, capable of seeping beneath the paint layer, causing bubbling, blistering, or even mold growth. The sun's relentless UV rays can fade and diminish the vibrancy of paint colors over time, irrespective of the underlying siding material.

While advancements in paint technology have produced formulas that are more durable and resistant to these challenges, no paint is truly immune. Consequently, homeowners should be aware that regardless of their chosen siding, a painted exterior will require regular inspections, touch-ups, and potentially, periodic repainting to keep it looking its best and offering optimal protection.


Duration

The longevity of a paint job is a crucial factor to consider when comparing it to siding options. Paint, no matter its quality, will eventually face the rigors of time, weather, and daily wear and tear. Even the best and most durable paints are susceptible to gradual degradation. Over a span of years, paint may lose its vibrancy, succumb to chips and cracks, or begin to peel, demanding the need for a fresh coat. In contrast, siding materials—be it vinyl, metal, or fiber cement—are engineered for durability and often come with warranties spanning decades. They're designed to withstand environmental stresses far longer before showing signs of wear or requiring replacement. This longevity means that while the initial investment for siding might be higher, homeowners may find it more cost-effective in the long run as they don't have to refresh or redo the exterior as frequently. Therefore, when contemplating the duration aspect, it's essential to view it not just in terms of immediate needs but also the long-term commitments and potential costs associated with periodic repainting.


A Deeper Dive into Wood Siding

Wood siding has an undeniable charm. It offers a timeless, natural beauty that many homeowners love. Repainting wood siding maintains this special appeal, allowing the wood grain to show through and preserving its authentic character.


However, wood is organic and thus more susceptible to elements. It can warp, rot, or get infested. Regular repainting not only keeps it looking fresh but also provides a layer of protection against these threats. Proper maintenance, which includes regular repainting, can extend the life of wood siding significantly.


It's worth noting, however, that maintaining wood siding demands commitment. It's generally more labor-intensive compared to vinyl or metal siding. But for those who cherish the unique beauty and warmth wood brings, the effort put into preserving it is often seen as a worthy investment. Repainting wood siding, when done right, ensures that your home retains its distinctive appeal, making all the hard work and dedication worthwhile.


Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Painting and Siding

Budget

One of the biggest pitfalls when homeowners go into any project is understanding the full scope of the budget requirements. While there is no way to go over every penny you will need to put aside for your specific project, we can give you some ideas of where to start and even come out and give you our best estimate.


Immediate Costs vs. Long-term Investment

Immediate Costs

Repainting typically comes with a lower immediate price tag, especially if done DIY. It's essential to factor in the cost of paint, supplies, and if you're not doing it yourself, labor charges.


Long-term Investment

While siding may have a heftier upfront cost, it could prove more economical in the long run due to its durability and reduced need for frequent maintenance or replacement. Consider the longevity of the material against the recurring costs of repainting every few years.


Material Costs

Paint: Prices can vary significantly based on the quality, brand, and specific features (like UV protection or mold resistance).

Siding: Costs range based on the material (vinyl, wood, metal, fiber cement), with some options being more premium and others more affordable. Remember, custom colors or finishes may add to the expense.


Labor Expenses:

Repainting: The cost can fluctuate based on the complexity of the job, the size of the house, and regional variations in labor charges.

Siding Installation: This often involves a higher labor cost due to the intricacies of installation, potential removal of old siding, and the need for specialized skills.


Maintenance and Future Costs:

Repainting: Factor in the potential need for touch-ups, repairs, or a full repaint every few years.

Siding: While maintenance costs can be lower, eventual replacement or repairs (due to damage or wear) should be considered.


Additional Expenses:

There might be preparatory work needed before either repainting or siding installation, such as repairing damaged areas or pre-treating surfaces. These preparatory steps can introduce additional costs. This is typically where you would set aside what is called a “contingency” budget of an additional 10-20% of the expected cost of the total repairs of the project.


When setting a budget, it's crucial to account for all potential expenses, not just the immediate ones. Obtain multiple quotes or estimates, do thorough research, and always factor in a little extra for unforeseen costs. Remember, the cheapest option now might not always be the most cost-effective in the long term.


Home’s Current Condition

Before deciding between painting and siding, a thorough assessment of your home's exterior condition is paramount. Here are some points to consider:


Extent of Damage

Minor imperfections such as small cracks, peeling paint, or slight discolorations can typically be addressed and prepped for a fresh coat of paint.


However, more extensive damage, such as rotting wood, large cracks in stucco, or persistent mold and mildew issues, may indicate deeper structural concerns. In such cases, simply painting over these problems could be a mere temporary fix.


Age of the Exterior

If the existing paint or siding is several decades old and showing signs of significant wear, it might be more beneficial in the long run to invest in new siding. This would offer not just an aesthetic upgrade but also enhanced protection against the elements.


Material Considerations

Some materials might be more amenable to painting, while others could benefit more from siding. For instance, a wooden exterior that's suffered from termite damage or extensive rot may not be the best candidate for repainting. Siding, especially a more durable option like vinyl or fiber cement, could provide a longer-lasting solution.


Underlying Issues

Sometimes, the visible damage is a symptom of a more profound issue. Water leaks, poor insulation, or inadequate vapor barriers can cause problems that paint alone can't rectify. In such instances, siding, which can be installed with integrated solutions to these issues, might be the better choice.


Resale Value and Longevity

If you're considering selling your home in the near future, think about how the exterior's current state might impact its market value. While a fresh coat of paint can boost curb appeal, new siding can elevate the property's value due to its durability and low maintenance appeal.


While paint can be a cost-effective way to refresh a home's appearance, it's crucial to ensure that the underlying structure is sound. If there are significant damages or concerns about the home's exterior integrity, siding could offer a more comprehensive and lasting solution.


Consult with a Professional

Even if you plan on doing everything yourself, it is important to get an expert opinion. While you may be capable of doing all the work yourself, you’ve done it all before, and you are completely comfortable taking it on. It is completely possible you might have missed something small that a professional eye may catch for you that can help in your project or may completely change your mind on doing it yourself. Before you grab your paint, give us a call for a free estimate today!


10 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page